In a single nine-day stretch this September, across a screened set of US small-cap companies, I counted four different arrangements for the chief financial officer role that were not simply “a CFO.”
- One company’s finance function was being run by an acting chief financial officer, and had been for months.
- Another appointed its president as interim CFO while a permanent search ran.
- A third terminated its CFO in a reorganization and had the chief executive assume the principal financial and principal accounting officer duties.
- A fourth, after its CFO retired, had the chief executive serve as interim CFO while a newly hired controller took on principal accounting officer.
None of this is unusual at small-cap scale. Finance leadership gaps are common, searches take months, and boards reasonably prefer a known quantity covering the seat to a rushed hire. What is less widely appreciated is that each of these arrangements creates a disclosure obligation that a normal CFO hire does not.
The compensation question nobody asks until the proxy
When an executive takes on a second officer role, someone has to decide whether they are paid more for it, and the proxy has to describe whatever was decided — including a decision to pay nothing extra.
That sounds trivial. In practice it is one of the harder benchmarking questions there is, because the comparison set barely exists. What is the market rate for a president who is also covering CFO for two quarters? There is no clean peer group for that. There is no survey line item. The committee is making a judgment with very little to anchor it.
The instinct is to treat it as immaterial and move on. That works right up until the arrangement lasts longer than expected, or the person ends up in the seat permanently, or a shareholder asks how the interim period was compensated and the answer has to be reconstructed after the fact.
Why interim arrangements distort the permanent package too
There is a second effect, and it is the one I find most consistently underestimated.
When an interim officer is eventually made permanent, the permanent package is very often set against the interim arrangement rather than against the market. It is the nearest reference point, it is internally defensible, and everyone in the room already knows the number.
But the interim arrangement was itself set without a real benchmark — it was a stopgap, priced for a few months of extra work. Anchoring a multi-year executive package to it compounds the original guess. Two thin decisions stack into one that has to survive a proxy cycle.
One company in this sample made exactly that transition in September: an interim chief executive was made permanent, at a $710,000 base with a 60% target bonus. That may well be the right number. But the honest question for the committee is whether it was derived from the market or from the interim deal, and those produce different answers more often than not.
The co-officer case
The most unusual structure in the sample came from a company that amended its bylaws to authorize co-chief executive officers, appointed two, and expanded the board from six to eight in the process. One of the two continues to serve as chief financial officer; the other continues as chief operating officer.
Set aside whether co-CEO structures work — opinions differ and the evidence is mixed. The compensation problem is concrete either way: two executive packages now cover one role, and there is almost no small-cap precedent to compare them against. A committee facing that has to build its comparison deliberately, because nothing off the shelf fits.
What to do about it
If your company is running any version of a split, acting, or doubled-up finance role, three things are worth doing before the next proxy rather than during it.
Write down what was decided about pay, and when. Including “no additional compensation.” A contemporaneous note is worth a great deal more than a reconstruction.
Benchmark the permanent role independently of the interim one. If the interim officer becomes permanent, the package should be tested against the market first and the interim arrangement second, not the other way around.
Decide in advance how long “interim” means. Arrangements that quietly persist are the ones that draw questions, because the disclosure stops matching the reality.
None of this is complicated. It is just easier to do while the decision is live than to reconstruct once the proxy is being drafted and the arrangement is a year old.
Observations drawn from 8-K filings dated September 1–9, 2026 across US operating companies between $20M and $1B in market value. Each filing was read individually.